You Be The Judge

Since people have been coming here looking for it here is video of the now infamous Tucker-Eaves scrap.

What are your thoughts? Did Tucker 'mug' him or did Eaves consent (under duress)?

Update:

Thanks to The Mad Hockey Blogger for unearthing these two videos. The first one shows McGrattan, the sens heavyweight, getting one-punched by Buffalo's Andrew Peters.

In the second one, Chris Neil shows that while he will gladly punch guys when they are being held sometimes a one-on-one fight can be too scary for him.

I hope these monsters don't take on the Leafs tonight!